Difference in differences log transformation


These differences are summarized in Table 1 below. This is a process labeled as logging in or log on to the system. If ra is greater than rb, the resulting value of z will have a positive sign; if ra is smaller than rb, the sign of z will be negative. One big difference, though, is the logit link function. We do  Transformations such as logarithms can help to stabilise the variance of a time . So, for the user, it could be sign in but for the system, it's log in. This can be valuable both for making patterns in the data more interpretable and for helping to meet the assumptions of inferential statistics. If the original data follows a log-normal distribution or approximately so, then the log-transformed data follows a normal or near normal distribution. _cons 3. Gavin decides that instead of conducting a 2 ´ 4 independent-groups factorial design, he is going to conduct a 2 ´ 4 within-subjects factorial design. The first is the lag, which is the number of periods, and the second is differences, We take a design perspective where we investigate the properties of estimators and procedures given assumptions on the assignment process. If we apply the same test to square root transformed differences we get an even lower P-value of 0. Where divergent time trends are observed, the difference-in-differences analysis may be biased since the estimated difference may be reflective of differences in trends of the outcome variable. Aug 31, 2018 particular, differences between log-values can be used as proxies . Between estimator This estimator is analogous, but here subtract the mean over time. -does the mean difference between two groups equal the null hypothesized value of udo? -one numerical response variable and a paired categorical explanatory variable with only two categories -assumes a random sample of pairs and that the variable is normally distributed in the population Our first question was whether there is a difference between the correlations that the two predictors family social support (FASS) and loneliness (RULS) have with the criterion variable stress. Whilst these terms are often used interchangeably – they are very distinct processes that have different outcomes, so it’s important to get clarity on what these terms are, and how they impact your organisation’s strategy. The only differences between these three logarithm functions are multiplicative scaling factors, so logically they are equivalent for purposes of modeling, but the choice of base is important for reasons of convenience and convention, according to the setting. Introduction. Difference in differences (DID or DD) is a statistical technique used in econometrics and quantitative research in the social sciences that attempts to mimic an experimental research design using observational study data, by studying the differential effect of a treatment on a 'treatment group' versus a 'control group' in a natural experiment. The MEANS, TRANSPOSE, and DATA steps use the saved estimated probabilities and log odds (xbeta) to compute the difference in difference of probabilities and of log odds. So, in this case, the naive transformation is the winner, but Duan's transformation beats the one that assumes normal errors. 16e+09 1. 什么是双重差分模型(difference-in-differences model)? 这一步,我们实际上算出了每个城市GDP的增长(率,如果取log之后 More on Prediction From Log-Linear Regressions. . A logarithmic transformation will give equal differences in the case of equal multiplicative  I have been urged by one reviewer to consider log transforming many of the variables in by computation of a geometric mean ratio (rather than a mean difference. Differences-in-Differences estimation in R and Stata. 91% = 3. In fact, there are many who thing that both are synonymous and either can be used to describe the act of getting inside a […] State how a log transformation can help make a relationship clear; Describe the relationship between logs and the geometric mean; The log transformation can be used to make highly skewed distributions less skewed. , T B = mean pre-treatment outcome) Treatment group Before T B After T A and then calculate the “difference” of the means: Treatment effect = (T A - T B ) Common Mistakes. The Root Mean Square Errors (RMSE's) of the forecasts are 1. Most statistical forecasting methods are based on the assumption that the time series can be rendered approximately stationary (i. 640 -1. Comparing the coefficient for census to that obtained in the prior model, we note that there is a big difference in coefficients; however, we must recall the scale of the dependent variable changed states. You can also analyze these data without transformation by using the t test with unequal variances. Transformation in SSIS is all done in-memory; after adding a transformation the data is altered and passed down the path in the Data Flow. e. Some Stata notes – Difference-in-Difference models and postestimation commands. Now is identified by variation in ys, xs, between individuals, not over time for same individual. The converse of login is logout where you are closing a browser or a website where you logged in, or simply turning off a system. The red dashed line in the right frame of Figure 1 has a slope of about 1. In principle, any log transformation (natural or not) can be used to transform a model that’s nonlinear in parameters into a linear one. This might sound too good to be true, and it is. Difference in differences (DID) Estimation step‐by‐step * Estimating the DID estimator reg y time treated did, r * The coefficient for ‘did’ is the differences-in-differences estimator. The log transformation is, arguably, the most popular among the different types of transformations used to transform skewed data to approximately conform to normality. , in absence of treatment, the unobserved differences between treatment and control groups arethe same First-difference estimator. 47 0. Difference in differences estimate () in essence is the difference between these two estimates for control and treatment groups, hence difference in percentages and thus should be interpreted as percentage point difference. If. icant differences with respect to forecasting accuracy. All log transformations generate similar results, but the convention in applied econometric work is to use the natural log. λ = 1: (No substantive transformation) λ = 1. The sampling distribution of the difference between means is all possible differences a set of two means can have. (yλ t − 1)/λ, λ = 0. Here is a table of different types of means for variable write. We show that under random assignment of the adoption date the standard Difference-In-Differences estimator is an unbiased estimator of a particular weighted average causal effect. are all constant over time. It is often used to measure the change induced by a particular treatment or event, though it may be subject to certain biases The difference between nonlinear and linear is the “non. The difference in differences of means requires that each of the four parts of the estimator be a mean rather than a log odds, and that requires applying the inverse of the link function to each of the four parts. In general, use into when movement, action or a transformation of state occur. 000001. Difference in Differences estimation in a log linear model. Half of them are given nothing: they are the control group. 0002. log transformation (lnY 0). The first-difference (FD) estimator is an approach used to address the problem of omitted variables in econometrics and statistics with panel data. Is that right or is there a difference (lol)? -a numerical response variable and categorical explanatory variable with only two categories -assumes: random sample, numerical variable is normal in both populations, standard deviation is same for both populations -Ho: The mu argument provides a number indicating the true value of the mean (or difference in means if you are performing a two sample test) under the null hypothesis. Johannes Mayr. Difference-in-difference estimation compares the change in the log of adult wages . In this segment we will cover equations with logarithms What is the difference between digital transformation and digital marketing? In order to understand the difference, we need to understand the meaning of each term. Summary of important EViews-Commands Import of data from EXCEL: if the xlsx-format does not work, use File. Percent effects are particularly appropriate for measures of athletic performance. See the diagram below; the four data points are the observed mean (average) of each group. 2. This is a system that has been made mandatory by nearly all websites to safeguard the activities of a user during a session after logging in. Remember that we used a log transformation to compute the confidence interval, because the odds ratio is not normally distributed. 1 Special case: Log transformation of the predictor. g. ” OK, that sounds like a joke, but, honestly, that’s the easiest way to understand the difference. To make our discussion less dry, she motivates the need for this cool technique in the context of mandated benefits. Calculate a difference of a series using diff () Higher order differences are simply the reapplication of a difference to each prior result. : When used in conjunction with differencing, logging converts absolute differences into  Difference-in-difference (or “diff-in-diff” or “DD”) estimation combines the (flawed) . The estimator is obtained by running a pooled OLS estimation for a regression of on . In the simplest quasi-experiment, an outcome variable is observed for one group before and after it is exposed to a treatment. DID is used in observational settings where exchangeability cannot be assumed between the treatment and control groups. Also, there are two kinds of logarithms in standard use: "natural" logarithms and base-10 logarithms. Difference in differences (sometimes 'Difference-in-Differences', 'DID', or 'DD') is a technique used in econometrics that measures the effect of a treatment at a given period in time. 10000. note that the parallel trends assumption may not hold for transformations of the data. Measures of Variability, Log Transformations, Differences between Two Means This difference in means shows clearly the degree to which benzodiazepine is  If you want to (for instance) compare disease rates in different states, simple When you do a log transformation, you are testing differences in  A one-tailed comparison gives a P-value of 0. In this case, the intercept is the expected value Logs In Regression We take a design perspective where we investigate the properties of estimators and procedures given assumptions on the assignment process. Difference Between it and that Difference Between In and On Difference Between Noun and Pronoun Difference Between In and At Difference Between Then and Than Filed Under: Grammar Tagged With: emphasizing particle , English as second language , English Grammar , English tutor , Grammar , in , in and inn , in and inside , in and on , in and out , inside , Learn English , locative adjectives , noun , preposition , within Can I assume you mean log transform the outcome? This is certainly an appropriate approach if your outcome is not normally distributed. Aug 31, 2018 Applying a log-transformation to normalized expression values is operate on relative rather than absolute differences in expression. image as the difference between log transformation of degraded image and log . Another important way is to express the difference as a fraction or multiple of a standard deviation. 718, raised to the Yth power. You split a population of sick people in two groups. Factorial Study-having more than one independent variable, or factor, in a stud. In social science, it is sometimes called a “controlled before-and-after” study. 58e+08 7. According to a dictionary, as for "color", you say "the difference in WordReference. A linear price scale uses an equal value between price scales In the case of a logistic model, it estimates the difference in differences of log odds (logits). 53, 1. Thus . Main Difference. In statistics, data transformation is the application of a deterministic mathematical function to However, following logarithmic transformations of both area and population, . Difference-in-Difference estimation, graphical explanation. The difference in differences (DiD) method is a statistical technique or quasi-experimental design method, and it is used primarily in the social sciences and econometrics. 5 This  The following illustration shows the histogram of a log-normal distribution (left When you select logarithmic transformation, MedCalc computes the base-10  log(yt), λ = 0;. My answer included this case; did you try the examples to understand the import of my advice? Though "mid the gap" was meant to read "mind the gap" meaning that if there are gaps in your time series in any panel then x-x[_n-1] is NOT the difference you want; you can check for that problem with gen dx=x-x[_n-1] if year==year[_n-1]+3 or just use lag operators as I suggested. This is fully attributable to the log-transformation, as no such difference is  Keywords: VAR-forecasting, logarithmic transformation. The mean difference, or difference in means, measures the absolute difference between the mean value in two different groups. Fixed effect estimator also called the WITHIN estimator. In today’s Public Finance III lecture @ Stanford, Professor Petra introduces one of the most widely used causal inference technique: difference-in-differences (diff-in-diff). In generalized linear models, instead of using Y as the outcome, we use a function of the mean of Y. 068). These are different from the log-linear models discussed here. If you're seeing this message, it means we're having trouble loading external resources on our website. In a linear difference-in-difference (DID) analysis, identification of causal effects hinge on a common trend assumption and interpretation of the estimated regression coefficient on the time x treatment interaction term. is correct. Percent differences are a natural way to express differences in the mean of variables that need log transformation. Table 1: The differences between transcription and translation I am wondering if there is any easy R commands or packages that will all allow me to easily add variables to data. Many types of statistical data exhibit a "variance-on-mean relationship", meaning that the variability is different for data values with different expected  Below is a linear model equation where the original dependent variable, y, has been natural log transformed. The assumptions of the proposed model are invariant to the scaling of the outcome. More on Prediction From Log-Linear Regressions. This is due to the fact that for longer racing times a small difference in If a logarithmic transformation is applied to this distribution, the  Aug 8, 2006 Although the log transformed data are still skew, the skewness is . 60 for WWF, WWFN, and WWFS respectively. Logs Transformation in a Regression Equation predictor (X) is put on a log scale. This function takes two arguments of note. Despite its wide use in statistics, the logarithmic transformation can make 100× ln( a )−100×ln( b )—it is the percentage difference between a and b . . com Language Forums 差分の差分分析(Difference-in-differences design) この前後比較デザインを改善したものがDIDになります。「前後比較デザイン」では自然経過のトレンドを考慮することができず、誤って政策の評価であるかのように見えてしまうことが問題です。 오늘 제가 올릴 글에서는 Differences-In-Differences (DID)라는 실증 분석 기법에 대해 간단하게 써보려 합니다. 3010$$ With my present understanding, I would interpret the result as follows: the number $2$ is $30,10\%$ greater than $1,$ which is obviously false. Here, the data are first transformed using logarithms (second panel), then seasonal differences are calculated (third panel). I am running 3 separate log-transformed differences-in-differences measuring the effects of a policy on state breastfeeding rates in the US separating control and treatment states with control states (=0) being states with no policy as well as states before the policy change and treatment states (=1) being states after the policy change. So if it holds on the original data, it will not hold on the logged data and vice versa. 6%. (EXP(Y) is the natural logarithm base, 2. (b) Very small differences in x, of size h, predict very small differences in E [Y ], of size 1. 191 (s. DD regressions are relevant when you can distinguish a control group and a treatment group. Teppei Yamamoto Difference in Differences Causal Inference 1 / 30. The interaction parameter estimates the difference in difference of log odds. Login vs Log On Do you login or do you log on to your computer and different websites? This is a question that is difficult to answer for even experts. This means that the counterfactual (unobserved scenario) is that had the treated group not received treatment, its mean value would be the same distance from the control group in the second period. The straight line has been replaced by an S-shaped curve that 1) respects the boundaries of the dependent variable; 2) allows for different rates of change at the low and high ends of the beer scale; and 3) (assuming proper specification of independent variables) does away with heteroskedasticty. As a result, you can more To distinguish seasonal differences from ordinary differences, we sometimes refer to ordinary differences as “first differences”, meaning differences at lag 1. In transcription, this polymerase moves over the template strand of DNA, while in translation, the ribosome-tRNA complex moves over the mRNA strand. 82, and 1. 3: Logs and seasonal differences of the A10 (antidiabetic) sales data. Some Stata notes – Difference-in-Difference models and postestimation commands Many of my colleagues use Stata (note it is not STATA), and I particularly like it for various panel data models. Differences in outcomes pre-treatment vs. , "stationarized") through the use of mathematical transformations. One of the big areas for confusion is around the meaning of the concepts of change and transformation. Take the impact of age on wages controlling for sex, with a positive coefficient for age. Differences-in-Differences Estimator Treatment= 1 for treatment group, 0 for control group After= 1 after the program, 0 before the program For treatment group, After the program Y= Before the program Y= The effect of the program: After-before For control group, After the program Y= Before the program Y= SQL Server Integration Services (SSIS) has transformations, which are key components to the Data Flow, that transform the data to a desired format as data moves from one step to another step. Log transformation could lead to very different results and hence different conclusions. Converting the difference to a percent is one way to make the difference dimensionless, and therefore more generic. Feb 3, 2018 Keywords: difference-in-differences; log-linearisation; Poisson Pseudo In general, no discussion of the impact of the log transformation on the  A. (각주1) DID는 어떤 정책이 특정 집단, 특정 기간에 시행 된 상황에서 그 정책이 경제에 미치는 순수한 영향만을 뽑아내고자 할 때 사용되는 기법입니다. 4. The logarithmic transformation corresponds to the choice λ = 0 by Tukey's convention. But, apart from those, it seems to me that the use of "in" and "on" after the plural "differences" is totally optional. Mar 17, 2011 Table 1: Four varieties of logarithmic transformations of response variables Y . frames which are the "difference" or change of over time of those variables. The log of a difference is NOT the difference of the logs. Log can be used in 2 instances, (i) when you need to interpret your results in percent changes or elasticities and (ii) to bring all variables to the same level (thereby getting rid of outliers in A logarithmic price scale uses the percentage of change to plot data points, so, the scale prices are not positioned equidistantly. 88e+09 Statistical stationarity: A stationary time series is one whose statistical properties such as mean, variance, autocorrelation, etc. For the US population, the logarithmic transformation applied to y makes the relationship almost perfectly linear. This is called a question about “correlated correlations. Logarithmic equations are equations involving logarithms. This means that if you are signing in for one session, the correct word is log in. 54% - 0. The first approach is to use the Maximum Likelihood method. so times we use inflation rate and sometimes we The logarithm transformation. Log transformation In log-log specification, has elasticity implication. Figure 8. The difference-in-difference (DID) evaluation method should be very familiar to our readers – a method that infers program impact by comparing the pre- to post-intervention change in the outcome of interest for the treated group relative to a comparison group. For complex-valued input, log is a complex analytical function that has a branch cut [-inf, 0] and is continuous from above on it. Hence, Difference-in-difference is a useful technique to use when randomization on the individual level is not possible. In R, the difference operator for xts is made available using the diff () command. Location of Restaurants Teppei Yamamoto Difference in Differences Causal Inference 2 / 30. The examples are used for illustrative purposes and are not intended to make substantive sense. Pairs of Completion Times and Their Differences for Example 2   Jun 1, 2012 Log transformations are one of the most commonly used transformations, but interpreting results of an analysis with log transformed data may  Aug 17, 2018 Log transformations are often recommended for skewed data, such as monetary . It is for this reason, content management software/portal like WordPress uses log in because it maintains the log each time you sign in 오늘 제가 올릴 글에서는 Differences-In-Differences (DID)라는 실증 분석 기법에 대해 간단하게 써보려 합니다. In the case of a logistic model, it estimates the difference in differences of log odds (logits). The log of a difference cannot be simplified. Lecture 5 - Difference in Difference 13:58 Difference in differences (DID) Estimation step‐by‐step * Estimating the DID estimator reg y time treated did, r * The coefficient for ‘did’ is the differences-in-differences estimator. Sometimes your data may not quite fit the model you are looking for, and a log transformation can help to fit a very skewed distribution into a more normal model (a “bell curve“). In this article, you learn how to do difference-in-difference in R. We hope you enjoyed the course and have learned something that you can use in your future work and research. Teppei Yamamoto. Oct 15, 2002 In logged form you estimate ln(y_i) = a_0 + a_1*D_i + error Here, a_1 gives the In the logged form, the difference, when transformed back to . Meet the Instructors. Identifying which transformation was performed between a pair of figures (translation, rotation, reflection, or dilation). Jan 12, 2018 skewness, two-part models, count models, difference-in-differences, . The only difference between the two is a scaling constant, which is not really important for modeling purposes. 2 Independence of Differences of Potential Outcomes Over . It seems that what you need are not difference in differences (DD) regressions. Log Transformation of a Skewed Distribution. δ → 0 corresponds to the natural log transformation model (14). variables are investments, defined as log differences of fixed assets less depreciation, and. Dr. MVD data in logs: 0. I would like to know the difference between "difference in" and "difference of". A subtle difference. These includes the test command, which does particular coefficient restriction tests or multiple coefficient tests, margins (and the corresponding marginsplot) which gives model based estimates at various values of the explanatory variables, and lincom and nlcom which I will show as being useful for differences in differences models. A link function is simply a function of the mean of the response variable Y that we use as the response instead of Y itself. Free logarithmic equation calculator - solve logarithmic equations step-by-step Linear models can also contain log terms and inverse terms to follow different kinds of curves and yet continue to be linear in the parameters. log handles the floating-point negative zero as an infinitesimal negative number, conforming to the C99 standard. I am confused about the interpretation of log differences. In the logged form, the difference, when transformed back to unlogged values, between the sexes increases with age. To test limits and to test theories. 61e+08 0. It means: you are refusing to indicate how many differences you think there are, and regardless of how many there really are, you only want to be told about one of them, respondent's choice. All variables were transformed using the inverse hyperbolic sine transformation which can be interpreted roughly as percentage changes. ” The two correlations being compared are not All average differences in ys or xs between individuals have been wiped out. e. 88e+09 Difference Between Login and Log On. In the unlogged form, the age lines for the sexes are parallel. This is the link function. log a (x - y) ≠ log a x - log a y An exponent on the log is NOT the coefficient of the log. 35; that is, the US population grew at a rate of about 35% per decade. In all derivations of the difference and differences from an aggression model, the average value of the residual term E is the same across all four groups, This paper develops a generalization of the widely used difference-in-differences method for evaluating the effects of policy changes. For example, parallel trends in Yit (z) implies non-parallel trends in log Yit (z) and vice versa. Sometimes it is necessary to take both a seasonal difference and a first difference to obtain stationary data, as is shown in Figure 8. The regression example below models the relationship between body mass index (BMI) and body fat percent. What you will get then is the absolute difference in height between the average female and the average male. xls Choice of sample period: Sample / You can also see that these correspond in the two period case Thus we have shown in the two period model-or multi-period model that the fixed effects estimator is just a difference in means, before and after the policy is implemented This is sometimes called the “difference model”. For example, She liked sitting in her grandfather's chair. The final module of the course deals with the difference in difference. : ( Square root plus Transformation often makes little difference to forecasts but has large When both seasonal and first differences are applied. Sampling distribution of the difference between means. is motivates the differences-in-differences estimator as the difference . That is, the natural log has been taken of each  The log-transformation can be done using the Excel function =LN(), using the ln button on . Ifo Institute void, a broad sample of models is employed over different estimation periods and forecast . Some individuals thinks that just about every so are equal phrases together with equal meanings. Here a simple example: $$\log(2)-\log(1)=. Login, log-on and sign-in would be the words utilized to get any working technique and internet site by means of using an authenticated or username and password. 0. The difference-in-difference method captures the significant differences in outcomes across the treatment and control groups, which occur between pre-treatment and post-treatment periods. The effect is significant at 10% with the treatment having a negative effect. When you do so , the  So the difference-in-differences in the growth rates are 4. Difference  I have performed a difference-in-differences but result shows that DID is not And in any case, the choice of whether to log transform a variable  Oct 21, 2005 Difference In Differences Methods . Difference against average and Normal plot for differences for CRP in 16  EDAListPlot can also use different symbols for the different data sets. [clarification needed] The FD estimator avoids bias due In this model, the dependent variable is in its log-transformed state, and the independent variable is in its original metric. Therefore, the confidence interval is asymmetric, because we used the log transformation to compute Ln(OR) and then took the antilog to compute the lower and upper limits of the confidence interval for the odds ratio. DID relies on a less strict exchangeability assumption, i. I'd choose the former when contrasting two things and the latter for more than two. Only for  Aug 7, 2015 Thus, LMMs have the potential to accommodate the different levels of However , on the log-transformed scale, differences between these two  Sal discusses the differences between linear and logarithmic scale. To perform the calculation, enter the respective values of r and n for the two samples into the designated cells, then click the «Calculate» button. Different This model is invariant to monotone transformations. DID requires data from pre-/post-intervention, such as cohort or panel data (individual level data over time) or repeated cross-sectional data (individual or group level). Compare this plot to the same plot for the correct model. post treatment cannot be attributed to . tiple differences are already apparent with two dimensions. Standard Difference-in-Differences Designs In its simplest form, the DD design can be illustrated in a 2×2 table, with the observed data illustrated in Table I . We propose a model that allows the control and treatment groups to have different average benefits from the treatment. The formula for the mean of the sampling distribution of the difference between means is: μ m 1 – m 2 = μ 1 – μ 2 "What is a difference" is grammatical, yes, but it's almost never what you want to say. Log transformation means taking a data set and taking the natural logarithm of variables. Any difference and difference across the two regions are interpreted as a causal effect of this smoking policy. In indicates location or state that is generally more static and not transitional. A standard simplified example would be the evaluation of a medecine. I mean to say that sometimes in the regression analysis we use the log of a variable and sometimes we use the growth rate of the same variable. Box-Cox Transformation: An Overview The inference on the transformation parameter The main objective in the analysis of Box-Cox transformation model is to make inference on the transformation parameter λ, and Box and Cox(1964) considered two approaches. software are the various post-estimation commands. Methodology. The dependent variable is the log difference of loans on firm i's balance sheet. In clinical trials, it gives you an idea of how much difference there is between the averages of the experimental group and control groups. The real difference is theoretical: they use different link functions. The DD estimate is the quantity in the lower right hand box, which can be thought of either as the change in the difference between groups across time, or the change across time in the difference between groups. ) measuring effects: should effects be measured as differences or as ratios,  Sep 30, 2015 in the expected response for a difference in f(x) of 1, not for a difference in x of 1. 01 change in Y Log-Linear 1 unit change in X 100 % change in Y Log-Log 1% change in X % change in Y € β 1 € Y i =β 0 +β 1 ln(X i)+u i € ln(Y i)=β 0 +β 1 X i +u i € ln(Y i)=β 0 SQL Server Integration Services (SSIS) has transformations, which are key components to the Data Flow, that transform the data to a desired format as data moves from one step to another step. A typical use of a logarithmic transformation variable is to pull outlying data from a positively skewed distribution closer to the bulk of the data in a quest to have the variable be normally distributed. In Statgraphics, the LOG function is the natural log, and its inverse is the EXP function. In the examples below, the variable write or its log transformed version will be used as the outcome variable. First, I’ll define what linear regression is, and then everything else must be nonlinear regression. Mar 30, 2015 For these slowest runners, the differences in completion times will be extremely large. The difference of the logs is the log of the quotient. Diff-in-diff robust to transformations of the outcome variable. The usage of "between" and "among" after the singular noun "difference" is quite clear to me. In many ways, logistic regression is very similar to linear regression. it makes no  Dec 18, 2018 the distribution before they are log transformed. ) Analysis of log-transformed height will give the difference between the females and males as a percent. Case Regression Specification Interpretation of Linear-Log 1% change in X 0. The Logit Link Function. The DiD estimate using the log transformed outcome is βlny  transformation of the outcome scale. Also one of my favorite parts of Stata code that are sometimes tedious to replicate in other stat. Differences: The Base Case One could take the mean of each group’s outcome with and without treatment (e. difference in differences log transformation

wj, tg, xn, 4a, br, fi, p4, yp, jn, px, fj, zx, q2, 6s, dg, lh, 7r, kx, qn, ys, xu, bg, pw, qz, io, tk, sx, no, lo, c4, 0m,